It might seem impossible for a great hotel to stay under the radar in New York City, where everything new and noteworthy gets hyped to death within, well, a New York minute. And yet, we've encountered a surprising number of charming, quirky, or underappreciated hotels that clearly deserve more attention than they get. Some folks would like these hidden gems to remain their own little secret. Sorry, guys.
Tourists often overlook the lovely, residential Upper West Side -- which is a shame. This 250-room Lucerne, in a tony red-stone building, gives tourists a taste of the local experience, and is close to great kid-friendly attractions like the Museum of Natural History and Central Park. Warm European decor and traditional, attentive service -- including 24-hour room service and a concierge who really knows the area -- make this a great pick for the price. The 1 subway line, which heads to Times Square, is only a block away.
As its name suggests, this 60-room boutique is designed according to literary theme: Bookshelves line the lobby; the floors and rooms are thematically organized according to the Dewey Decimal system; and it's located a block from both New York's famous Public Library (not to mention the transportation hub of Grand Central). It's got a solid upscale bistro on the ground floor, a lively rooftop bar on the penthouse floor, and offers free Wi-Fi, gym passes, and daily pastries, wine, and cheese.
The Casablanca is a homey boutique hotel in a location where homey boutiques are scarce -- the heart of Times Square. This is a great option for tourists who want to be near some the city's most popular attractions but prefer to avoid the area's many mega-properties. The amenities can't compete with those of a larger hotel, but the staff is wonderfully warm and guests enjoy free coffee and popcorn all day and daily wine and cheese receptions from 5 to 8 p.m.
Originally built as lodging for sailors in 1908, the Jane Hotel is adjacent to the meatpacking district and conveniently located near the High Line and Whitney Museum. Their standard cabins and bunk rooms have shared baths, but their Captain Suites feature an ensuite bathroom. Book the Jane for a truly unique stay.
Located in the heart of SoHo, The Broome is an intimate boutique hotel with just fourteen rooms. Inspired by French design, the intimacy, and style, complete with a European-style courtyard and farm-to-table complimentary breakfast, make for a distinctive stay. Their newest addition is their online bar, “Wine at the Broome” - offering a selection of craft wines and an assortment of cheeses and charcuterie.
Sticking with our theme of hotels that were formally something else, the Box House Hotel is a former door factory with spacious suites, apartments, and a penthouse available for your stay- all decorated with original artwork. Located in Brooklyn, there is an on-site, full-service restaurant and bar, a retractable rooftop available for events, and complimentary tea and coffee.
Nestled in two 19th-century brownstones in Gramercy Park, Irving Place makes you feel like you’ve stepped back in time. With just twelve rooms, all furnished with antiques, it feels more like a residence than a hotel, and will have you looking around for your butler to bring in your trunks. Enjoy afternoon tea at the on-site Lady Mendi’s Tea Salon.